16 Gilmore Girls details I still can’t quite make sense of

If you ask me, Gilmore Girls is the ultimate comfort show. As much as I sometimes wish I could experience the Gilmores’ story for the very first time again, I have to admit that I enjoyed it almost as much on my second rewatch (and I’m currently in the middle of my third marathon). It’s always easy for me to slip back into the warm atmosphere of the fictional town of Stars Hollow, where everything and nothing happens at the same time. The show isn’t packed with action or dramatic twists, but I think that’s exactly why so many people find it so soothing. I always know what it will give me: sharp humor, mostly warm family dynamics, a crowd of wonderfully eccentric characters, and a lot of coffee.

It’s also the perfect show to have on in the background when you just need comforting noise or, if you’re a tablet child like me, something to watch while you eat. Still, even though I know the entire plot and can easily match almost any quote to the character who said it, I have to admit that Gilmore Girls still manages to surprise me. Maybe it’s because they talk so fast, or because they reference an endless list of 2000s pop-culture moments I didn’t grow up with, but during my first watch — when all I cared about was finding out whether Rory would get into Harvard and how many chances Lorelai would give Chris — a lot of things slipped past me. Which is why I believe the true brilliance of the show only becomes clear when you slow down and pay attention to all its layers.

I love this series so much that I want to understand it inside out, so I went down a little rabbit hole to try and make sense of every detail that either confused me or still catches me off guard.

@gilmoregirls

Why do the Gilmore Girls talk so fast?

When I first started watching Gilmore Girls, I didn’t notice their unbelievably fast pace at all. Maybe it’s because I’m a yapper myself, but the tempo felt surprisingly natural to me — they’re always on the move and drinking gallons of coffee, after all. I only noticed the unnatural speed once people pointed it out. Now, when I rewatch the show, I can’t believe it took me so long to catch on to just how quick their conversations are, which is one of the show’s defining traits. But to be fair, I watch everything with closed captions on.

The speed was intentional. The cast even had a dialogue coach, George Bell, who used a barometer to help them deliver their lines at the right pace while still sounding clear. A single episode of Gilmore Girls includes so much dialogue that scripts often ran up to 80 pages. For comparison, a typical one-hour episode of most shows is around 40 to 50 pages. But the dialogue is part of the show’s charm. In fact, most major events aren’t shown directly on screen — we hear about them through conversations between the characters (like when Richard collapses during the Christmas dinner or when Lorelai calls off her engagement). Instead of trimming the dialogue to fit standard runtime, creator Amy Sherman-Palladino simply decided the characters would talk faster.

How is this everything Lorelai had in her closet?

Warner Bros. Television

When Rory heads to her new prestigious school for the first time, Lorelai complains that she forgot to pick up her clothes from the dry cleaner, which forces her into assembling a rather chaotic outfit. I can believe that Lorelai Gilmore put off doing laundry long enough for almost everything she owns to be dirty, but I refuse to believe that her closet, which we know is full of great outfits, held nothing but shorts and a T-shirt she paired with a coat. Even if I accept the idea of a completely empty closet, that still doesn’t explain the cowboy boots she finished the look with. Then again, now that we know about the wrong shoe theory, maybe Lorelai was simply ahead of her time.

What happened to the woman with the harp?

It’s well known that pilot episodes often introduce characters who later disappear or get recast. In the first four episodes of Gilmore Girls, the Independence Inn staff includes a sarcastic harpist named Drella (played by Alex Borstein). I always wondered what happened to her and why her character suddenly vanished. Interestingly, in the pilot, Alex Borstein was originally cast as Sookie but had to give up the role due to scheduling conflicts. She still appeared as Drella in the early episodes, and later returned to the series twice, once as Emily’s stylist, Miss Celine, and once as the voice of Lorelai’s very irritated neighbor.

Courtesy of Warner Bros

Kirk is not just kirk

Kirk is easily one of the most memorable characters in Stars Hollow — you simply can’t miss him, especially considering he held 62 different jobs over the course of the series. But before he officially became Kirk, actor Sean Gunn appeared on the show as two entirely different characters: Mick, the guy who installs DSL at the Gilmore house, and a delivery worker bringing swans to the Independence Inn. His first appearance as Kirk happens later, when he shows up as the assistant manager at Doose’s Market.

@gilmoregirls

1,000 Daisies

One of the most romantic gestures in the series is when Max Medina sends Lorelai 1,000 daisies after she jokes that that’s what a proper proposal requires. The scene is unforgettable: florists filling the Independence Inn lobby with bright yellow flowers. But the space isn’t actually filled with 1,000 daisies the way Lorelai imagined. It’s not because Max was cutting corners, quite the opposite. It took far more than a thousand daisies to create that dramatic effect.

Amy Sherman-Palladino later explained that while “a thousand” sounds like a lot, in a large room like the one on their set, 1,000 daisies take up far less space than we imagine

Courtesy of Warner Bros.

How did Carole King end up in Stars Hollow?

Carole King, the Rock & Roll Hall of Fame legend, performs the show’s signature opening theme, Where You Lead, together with her daughter Louise Goffin. But that’s not her only appearance in the series. She also plays Lane’s mentor and the owner of the local music shop, Sophie Bloom. The cameo makes absolutely no sense if you think about it too literally — someone as music-obsessed as Lane would definitely recognize Carole King, but maybe Sophie is simply her small-town doppelgänger.

Why does luke never take off his hat?

Is he hiding thinning hair? I always suspected there was a story behind his costuming, but I didn’t expect it to be this sweet. Early in the series, Luke constantly wears an olive-green baseball cap. That changes when Lorelai buys him a navy one, which he then wears for several seasons, subtly signaling his feelings for her. He only takes it off after their breakup, replacing it, very fittingly, with a black cap.

Courtesy of Warner Bros.

Dean’s slow decline

The character who started out as the dreamy new guy from the city trying to adjust to small-town Stars Hollow eventually spiraled into becoming one of the show’s most disliked characters, Rory’s first boyfriend, Dean. I’ll start by saying I genuinely think Dean was a very good first boyfriend for Rory. Even though he wasn’t a reader himself, he followed her into bookstores, showed up at the pretentious events hosted by her grandparents, and, let’s not forget, built her a car. Still, I understand why many would label him the worst of Rory’s boyfriends. I wouldn’t say he was a terrible partner as much as he was a character who got slowly written into the ground.

Courtesy of Warner Bros

Dean started out as someone who genuinely understood Rory’s references — he won her over instantly with a Rosemary’s Baby nod — and he fit naturally into the rhythm she had with Lorelai. Over time, though, he became possessive and petty, acting like he had nothing in his life besides Rory and making unnecessary comments about her education. He also had zero ambition. The perfect definition of “she’s everything, he’s just Ken.” And to be clear: when I say he was a good boyfriend, I mean only up until the moment Rory left him for Jess, because everything that happened after that was wrong on so many levels.

How was Rory the Valedictorian?

I think everyone is aware of how wildly unrealistic the people of Stars Hollow are when it comes to Rory. Yes, she’s a smart girl they all watched grow up, but it’s still hard to believe that literally everyone adores her. Dean even calls this out at one point with the completely valid line, “Well, too bad, Rory. Somebody doesn’t like you for once.” I always found it strange how everyone seemed to worship her, but it did add a certain charm to Stars Hollow and showed the audience who the Gilmores were through the eyes of their neighbors. Still, one thing that makes absolutely no sense is that Rory is named Valedictorian at her prestigious school. Not because she couldn’t do it, the show goes out of its way to present her as hardworking, smart, and well-read, but because the title should have gone to someone else.

When Rory first transferred to Chilton, she struggled. She got less-than-stellar grades and needed time to adjust before becoming one of the strongest students. Those early grades alone would have taken her out of the running for Valedictorian. Meanwhile, Paris had consistently excellent grades from day one, on top of being editor of the school paper. And let’s not forget: Rory was announced as Valedictorian before she even took her final exams. But anything is possible when you’re the main character.

Courtesy of Warner Bros

How did Paris not get into Harvard?

Let me continue listing the injustices done to Paris. Sure, she wasn’t always the most likable character, but we’re talking about a teenage girl completely neglected by her parents, trying to earn their attention through academic achievement. What can’t be denied is her dedication to school, extracurriculars, and racking up every possible point needed for college admissions. Even if we assume she had the same grades as Rory, the sheer amount of volunteer work and additional activities she did would mathematically put her ahead.

We do see her have a disastrous interview at Harvard, where she doesn’t exactly show her best self, but even that doesn’t fully justify the rejection. The reality, of course, is that the writers wanted to keep her in the show’s main storyline, and I’m genuinely glad she ended up at Yale, it let us follow her growth much more closely.

Where did Tristan go?

To other shows. Tristan was a fun character to watch, especially because of his banter with Rory and the chaos he added to her dynamic with Paris. That’s why his sudden exit, being sent to military school, always felt so strange. It turns out actor Chad Michael Murray landed roles on Dawson’s Creek and One Tree Hill around the same time.

What made this even sadder for me was learning that Logan’s character was originally conceived as a kind of replacement for Tristan (and if you think about it, there are more parallels than just both being blond). It would have been nice to follow his arc from high school through college, just like we did with Paris, but even though he wasn’t physically there, I’m glad the show at least kept traces of his energy in later storylines.

@gilmoregirls

Where does Rory’s nickname “Ace” come from?

Speaking of Logan, we have to admit he gave Rory a much sweeter nickname than Tristan ever did, calling her Ace instead of Mary. Not long after they met, Logan started using it to tease her, which annoyed Rory at first because she saw him as just another smug, privileged guy. But she eventually falls for this charming, sarcastic character who, in my opinion, is her best boyfriend in the entire series (nothing can change my mind). And the nickname itself makes it pretty clear that Logan was the one who fell first.

Courtesy of Warner Bros

He read Rory pretty quickly and understood she was the kind of girl who works hard, sets goals, and tries to excel at everything she does. “Ace” is a nickname for someone who’s the best at something, and it sums Logan up perfectly (sweet with a sarcastic edge). With that one word, he’s teasing her and showing affection at the same time.

Why is the dog named Paul Anka?

This was honestly one of my biggest questions while watching the show. First, I had to Google who Paul Anka even was, and once I learned he was a musician, I was even more confused. Lorelai renames the rescue dog Cocco to Paul Anka, and she must have had a reason. The reference is actually pretty simple. Writer Dan Palladino explained that he imagined Lorelai hearing a Paul Anka album one day while grabbing her morning coffee, and the name just stuck in her head. And if we really want a deeper connection, Paul Anka does have a song called Puppy Love, which makes the choice a little sweeter.

What happened to Dave?

During my first watch, I’ll admit I didn’t immediately notice the absence of Lane’s boyfriend Dave. He’s a side character, and since Lane herself isn’t in every episode, it was easy to miss. It wasn’t until she started developing a new crush in the band that I realized it had been a while since Dave appeared. So where did he go?

Just like Tristan, Dave left the show because the actor, Adam Brody, landed a major role on another series, The O.C.. This was a sad moment for most Gilmore Girls fans, because Dave and Lane were a genuinely great match, and he was one of the strongest male characters on the show. One of his sweetest gestures is when he reads the entire Bible in one night to impress Lane’s mother. I know it’s meant to be dramatic, but it still haunts me a little, because reading the Bible actually takes more than 24 hours. Maybe Dave has some kind of speed-reading superpower. If so, I’d love for him to share it.

Courtesy of Warner Bros

Luke didn’t tell Lorelai about April

I think we can all agree that Luke isn’t exactly a master communicator,Lorelai even points this out in earlier seasons, but their romantic relationship grew out of a long, genuine friendship, which makes it even harder to understand why he would hide something so major from her. It was difficult to believe that Luke would let Lorelai slip away after spending at least a decade quietly pining for her. The entire plotline felt unconvincing, mostly because the idea that Luke has a child from a past relationship doesn’t really track. Aside from Rachel, none of his exes were ever mentioned, and by my calculation, April would’ve had to be born around the time he was first with Rachel.

We also already saw Luke in a parental role with Jess, so bringing April into the story didn’t add anything new, it just introduced a soap-opera twist that didn’t feel organic to the show. In general, season six is when everything flipped upside down and turned chaotic. Some fans believe it’s tied to behind-the-scenes disagreements between Amy Sherman-Palladino and the network, since Palladino left after that season. Either way, child or no child, I don’t believe this was ever meant to be the deal-breaker for Luke and Lorelai, especially since the entire show proves again and again that they know how to work through their conflicts.

Rory turns down Logan

My Roman Empire. I could list reasons until tomorrow explaining why Rory rejecting Logan will never make sense to me. No one can convince me that turning down a proposal from the man she lived with, loved, and who offered her a stable, promising future was a logical move. Sure, of course we all wanted to see Rory succeed on her own, chase her dreams, and not depend on a man. But unlike her other boyfriends, Logan never held her back. If anything, this moment only highlights how her character never truly developed — we see the exact same fear of commitment we saw in season one.

@gilmoregirls

When you add Rory’s storyline in A Year in the Life on top of that, her decision looks even worse. I want to believe Palladino originally planned for Rory and Logan to be endgame before she left the show, and it might actually be true, considering they end up (sort of) together again in the revival she wrote, and that Logan is almost certainly the father of Rory’s child.

All things considered, Gilmore Girls is far from perfect. There are plenty of inconsistencies and plot holes that I choose to ignore, simply because I enjoy its charm too much to let them get in the way.